Tag: Economics

Anatomy Of A Bubble

I’m not convinced that we have seen the bottom in housing. I’m not convinced that we have seen a successful soft landing either. Things definitely slowed down going into the end of 2006, and they are definitely picking up again in early 2007. But I don’t see any reason to believe we will return to the hyperbolic growth we saw in previous years – or anything close to it. In fact, there still is some very real concern that we could see a more significant drop in house values.

The Federal Reserve is expected to keep rates flat all year. Some economists think we will see a rate cut late in the year, and some see a rate hike a possibility still. History tells us that the Fed usually starts cutting rates within 9-18 months of their last rate hike.

I have often said that with so many variables in the economy, and in the housing market specifically, all it can take is one environmental change to trigger a shift in consumer mentality, and thus consumer behavior. One of these variables that has re-entered the fold in the last few weeks is Wall Streets control over mortgage lending practices. With sub-prime lenders going out of business, Wall St. has raised concern with sub-prime mortgage backed securities. The lenders are responding by tightening their lending guidelines to uphold or improve their credit ratings.

A year ago, congress was advising the lending industry to do this, but lenders were actually relaxing guidelines in an effort to grab more of the shrinking volume of business. So with this pendulum swinging back the other way, you can expect the fringe of buyer access to be trimmed away, thereby reducing the pool of potential buyers, demand, housing liquidity, and ultimately prices. If lenders go too far too fast, either by their own proactive measures, or in response to Wall St. demand, we could see a shock to this system. And if the consumer perceives this to be significant, thats when the potential to freeze up and panic sets in.

Weakening prices slow what Paul Kasriel of Northern Trust refers to as ‘household deficit spending’, as homeowners cannot spend their home equity on other consumer purchases. If you don’t think this is a big deal, take note of the fact that the US Savings rate is at its lowest since the GREAT DEPRESSION, at a negative 0.5%. People are using their homes like ATM’s on a National level. Cutting off access to this slows spending, and the economy in general. Enough of this and the Fed is back into rate-cutting territory.

So while I hear agents advising their clients that “the bubble has not burst“, and that offers without contingency and 10% above the asking price are required “if you really want this home”, I don’t like anybody being too anxious to lead with logic when transacting in real estate. It is competitive right now, yes. But I’d be concerned that the housing market is making a head-fake here.

Real Estate and Tax – What’s Important To Know

With tax season officially open for the 2006 filing year, its time to refresh the memory on some important tax issues related to real estate. I see a great deal of confusion and misinterpretation of tax rules when meeting with people in my mortgage planning practice. Realty Times has a good reminder on the homestead exepmtion that Bill Clinton gave us with the Tax Reform Act of 1997. Make sure you know the rules for this tax treatment on homes in the year they are sold – especially if you are thinking about renting the home out at any point. Its also important to know the difference between mortgage interest expense and investment interest expense when trying to write off those mortgage and HELOC dollars. I see the majority of people surprised when confronted with the rules for deduction of mortgage interest. The IRS is talking about taking a closer look at these deductions to make sure tax-payers are walking on the right side of this fine line…

You can find a lot of tax resourse on the IRS website, but you may want to consider letting a professional CPA handle your taxes for you. The more complicated your return, the more value a tax planner stands to offer. Let me know if you need help locating a good one.

SF Fed President Janet Yellen Speaks on Housing, Economy

I like the general sentiment in Janet Yellen’s speech yesterday regarding the state of our economy. Since Economists are generally regarded as dry and boring, I don’t expect you to want to read yourself – that’s why I talk about it here. But if you’re in the mood, feel free here. Lots of other stuff I am reading gets posted on this page as well.

I keep writing about the different vibes being given by credible sources on our economy, where we are headed, and what the implications are for the housing market. Yellen’s speech yesterday gives some great insight into the mindset of the Fed right now, and what they are confident about and what they are uncertain about. The general idea is that we are seeing increasing evidence of the ‘soft landing’ scenario.

You get a great idea of how dynamic the economy is when reading this, as there are so many variables that play into the evaluation, and each one affects the others in direct and indirect ways. Along these lines, as many people are watching the economy to make predictions about housing, others are looking at housing to make predictions about where the economy will go. Sometimes its difficult to see which comes first.

We see analysis that suggest home equity borrowing has specifically contributed as much as 1% to the annual GDP growth. With a current rate of 2-3%, that’s a significant portion! With the 17 consecutive rate hikes to the Fed Funds and Prime rates, consumer demand for dollars should drop, slowing spending, and slowing economic growth… Those cuts seem to be working….

A few months ago everybody thought that the Fed was impatient with their pace of rate hikes, and should wait longer to see the early part of the cycle make its way through to GDP figures (arguably a 9-24 month lag time). The fear was that they would slow us too aggressively and put is in recession. (Then we get rate cuts, go the other way to stimulate spending, etc… the so-called pendulum swinging back and forth…) But This side of the rate cycle is looking now to be one of the longest pauses at the top on record. This could change with a big miss either way in CPI, Jobs data, PCE, or other economic reports, but so far things are looking pretty healthy.

Look at this quote from Yellen’s speech: “…it looks as if the economy is pretty close to the ‘glide path’ I mentioned before – growth has slowed to a bit below most estimates of the economy’s long-run potential, while the risk of an outright downturn has receded.” So much for the pendulum getting ready to swing the other way… its on a nice slow drift into place.

We still expect to see corrections in the yield curve, but the threat of inflation needs to be fully contained first. Still a glimmer left… As I like to say, there are a lot of moving targets out there. The sentiment can change quickly. But for now, it looks as though the big picture is in a fair amount of control.

Are We Going To See A Soft Landing?

The news media has covered the real estate market in the last few years with close attention. As prices have soared to historic highs, some economists have speculated that the value growth has been unsustainable, and that we are headed for a painful value correction. Fear of what the implications of this scenario would look like has fueled the media coverage – remember, they love to keep you on your toes.

Going a little beyond the scope of the nightly news, you might be able to get a more credible view on where we are headed. After all, there’s a million Economists out there getting paid a million dollars to research, digest data, and speculate as to where we are headed, but they are often not as ‘exciting’ as your 11 o’clock news anchor… Because of the immensely dynamic national and world economy, these Economists are all over the board with their predictions. And when the consensus gets scattered, we get that feeling of uncertainty that might make the American consumer take pause (for what it means to the economy when the American consumer takes pause, consult your local Economist… I told you: dynamic!!). There are a lot of contradictory opinions floating around out there – I know, because I read the boring Economist stuff. As a Mortgage Planner I keep a pulse on these things and make recommendations that respect your financial objectives within the context of the mortgage landscape and the economic environment at the time – and going forward.

You can get an idea of what these pundits are looking at to make their assessments of our economy, and register their opinions. It may not be exciting stuff to everybody, but it helps to know where they are coming from. Here are a few items that they are watching to see if we are in fact headed for a “soft landing”. In general, inflation concerns bring higher rates, and make housing less affordable.

RETAIL SALES Report: This comes out monthly and shows the mood of the American consumer. Strong sales indicate that businesses are making profits, and that the economy should keep cooking. Too strong a report suggests too much money floating around, and an environment where inflation can run too high – that can lead to higher interest rates. Sharp declines in this report suggest that the opposite. A precursor to a “hard landing” might be a sharp downturn in this report.

TRANSPORTATION COMPANIES: When companies like FedEx and UPS lower their outlooks or speak of declines in activity, it suggests the American consumer is slowing spending.

DURABLE GOODS Report and BUSINESS CAPITAL EXPENDITURES (CapEx): : Shows when businesses are spending (and growing or looking to grow) and expand capacity for production. The report gives an indication of upcoming manufacturing activity, and when this slows there can be inflationary pressure.

ISM INDEX: Manufacturing index of industrial companies that signals expansion and contraction in this sector.

MORTGAGE FORECLOSURE Rates: When these pick up, it suggests lending guidelines will tighten and shrink the pool of buyers. This lowers demand, and can accelerate a decline in housing activity.

AUTO SALES: A recession predictor, the economy often flows in the same direction as Auto Sales.

Hey, wake up! If you made it through all of that, you might want to consider a career as an Economist – we could use some help figuring out if we are in fact headed for a “soft landing” or not.

Interest to Remain Moving Target in 07

The rolling economic data is keeping Ben Bernanke and the Federal Reserve on their toes. And in return, the Fed is keeping the investment community on their toes. As recently as 3 months ago, the futures market had a probable interest rate cut predicted as soon as December 06. By the time December rolled around, those odds had faded, and now, nothing is expected until the third or fourth quarter – if at all.

The Fed is still eyeing inflation as their greatest concern. They have continued to suggest that the “extent and timing of additional firming” will depend on this incoming rolling data. The bias is in fact on a tightening as the next move, but its a pretty modest one at this point.

Through the eyes of Real Estate Finance and Mortgage Planning, this has rates continuing to stay in a narrow range, and they are expected to do so through much of the year.

What Happens when Everybody is Talking About Housing?

“Housing Decline” was the most talked about news item of the year in 2006, according to a recent AP article. This probably comes as a surprise to nobody. But to what extent does consumer sentiment about housing have an impact on the underlying values? Or is it just a good way to get a barometric reading on the financial aspects of the market?

Back in 1999 when I was working as a financial advisor, I remember reading several articles that discussed the relationship between news reporting frequency of key terms and the financial performance of the related commodity. Back then, all the talk was about the stock market, and mutual funds, which had become so prolific that they outnumbered the number of individual stocks listed in the US Market. Inexperienced investors were being drawn to the stock markets in droves, and prices were flying with the influx of new money. On occasion, even hip-hop music – historically boastful about financial prowess – made mention of mutual funds amidst its more commonly urban references.

The significance of this was that the more there was mention of a sentiment in the news media and pop culture, the more likely it was that momentum was being driven to an unsustainable level. We saw it come in 2000, when the stock market hit a major correction. The worst of the decline was felt in the NASDAQ, where most of the new investors had been drawn to the recent fast-paced technology company returns.

We saw it again last year in housing, when everybody seemed to be talking about buying houses, with ‘no money down’ and making ‘positive cash-flow’ from the start. All of these infomercial testimonials with the ‘average couple’ sitting by a pool at a resort in Orlando, discussing how much passive income they received in the previous month… it was a sign that the market was over-heated.

Charles Kindleberger notes in his famous anatomy of a crash Manias, Panics and Crashes that “when the world is mad, we must imitate…”, capturing the essence of the fuel that is the consumer in pursuit of ROI. Even when we know something is too good to be true, there can be an urge to get involved. If you don’t, you risk getting left behind. To this end, the American consumer has the ability to self-fulfill its own prophecy, but it typically leads to excesses, and the last guy in gets left holding the bag. So far the ‘housing decline’ seems to be moderate in most markets – but not all. Its going to be easy to see in retrospect where the market got overheated. I’ve discussed it here before, and I will continue to as we cycle through this market.

—

Heres a link to some economist sentiment for 2007

Blowing Bubbles…

Are we headed for a soft landing? The media has been beating the ‘real estate bubble’ drum for several years, and in doing so scaring countless would-be homeowners out of buying what would have been a nice investment, not to mention a nice place to call home. But now we are seeing a counter-weight of similar magnitude, in real estate professionals and industry insiders who clamor for the so-called “soft landing” in the housing market.

Stepping back a bit and looking at housing from an economic perspective we might be able to take some of the hot air out of the equation and see what is really happening. Housing is an investment, and an asset in a class of its own based on the function it serves relative to other types of investments. But real estate is still subject to market conditions, cycles, and other typical financial rhythms.

There is no question that housing has seen tremendous gains in recent years, exhibiting characteristics of ‘irrational exuberance’ that have paved the way to inflated asset prices and preceded significant corrections in value. The most recent memorable example was the NASDAQ and dotcom stock rally that came to an end in 2000. From the peak of the rally to the trough of the correction, the index lost a staggering 71%

Commentary on the asset bubble phenomenon most commonly references a mania in the market for Dutch tulip bulbs during the 1630’s, where at the height of the market, people were swapping homes for flower bulbs.

In Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds, Charles Mackay wrote “that whole communities suddenly fix their minds upon one object, and go mad in its pursuit.” Is this what we have seen in the US housing market in recent years?

The characteristics of a cycle turning over are present in the housing market. First we saw a parabolic curve in home values. The Federal Reserve stepped in to raise rates (while the general goal was to curb inflation, it is very likely that the specific goal was to temper home values), and eventually inventory increased. Now prices are starting to come down.

Paul Kasriel of Northern Trust recently published that in the current housing rally, the dollar volume of all sales was at a record high when represented as a percentage of GDP. The implication is that this is an extreme market, and that we should be facing a similarly extreme correction.

Given that the housing market continued to rally in the face of the Fed rate hikes, demand was defined as ‘inelastic’. In other words, people did not care that it was becoming more expensive to buy; they just used more liberal loan products, taking on increased risk, and kept on spending. It took 17 hikes of 0.25% each before the market showed a change in mood.

Several economists think that the Fed tightened rates well beyond the neutral point, and expect them to start lowering as soon as January 2007. Cool the jets with higher rates, then slowly ease back into the comfort zone. Its like getting into a car that has been parked in the sun: put the AC on full blast for 10 minutes, and you’ll eventually need to back off and find the middle ground.

Paul McCully at PIMCO recently made the case that all of this suggests that a ‘soft landing’ in housing is nothing but a pipe dream. Demand for housing, he says, is inelastic on the way down, just as it is on the way up. Once the investors change sentiment, rate cuts are not going to bring them back in droves. We saw this with the NASDAQ, and stock market in general. It took an over-correction and under-valued securities to bring the interest back to Wall Street.

So is housing due for an over-correction? Is the ‘soft landing’ attainable? Kasriel and McCully make for an interesting case. Next we will look at the Kubler-Ross model laid down over the US housing market, and see if we can find any similarities.

Recession 2007! … ?

How many economists does it take to hit a moving target?

The financial and economic communities are abuzz with tension right now, as the Federal Reserve is undoubtedly fine-tuning the structure of their remarks in tomorrow’s policy meeting. A few weeks ago the markets were betting heavily on this meeting to be the first where the Fed did not raise rates since they began the current tightening policy in June of 2004. As I have mentioned before, the CPI numbers have been supporting the notion that inflation in the US economy is uncomfortably high. And for the last several weeks, the Fed Governors have been popping up all over the place, like a giant game of Whack-a-Mole, peppering the news with one common sentiment: Inflation persists, and is of current concern to the US Federal Reserve.

Its a different picture than a few weeks ago. This whip-saw reading on the economy is unkind to the markets, which have seen a consistent down-turn accross asset classes in the past month. Whether this is a modest correction or a trend reversal is yet to be determined. So is the economy slowing down? Is inflation still too high? The worst case would be “yes” to both.

We sit today with the markets 100% convinced that rates will be hiked tomorrow, 0.25%, to a Fed Funds rate of 5.25%. Some believe we could see a more definitive move to 5.50%. More think we will see 5.50% in August. And some think the ‘terminal rate’ will be as high as 6.00%.

What does this imply for our economy in the near future? As usual, there is a rainbow of opinion out there right now, ranging from healthy to worrisome. But its not the same old boom-time we have seen in recent years; current forecasts mention words like Recession, Stagflation, Asset Bubbles, etc:

  • Along with the Fed, other central banks in the world are tightening, taking liquidity out of the system. The Bank of Japan has had a huge impact recently, to the tune of some $200 billion over the last few months according to George Soros. This is in the process of throwing a cold shower at the global economy.
  • Commercial banking guidelines remain very liberal, but the tightening of liquidity on this level will be the likely next step, according to John Mauldin. Goodbye easy institutional money, and goodbye easy consumer money. How can we continue to spend and propel the economy at this pace?
  • The folks at Northern Trust provide some discourse on the inverted yield curve, and second-guess the popular notion that ‘this time it’s different’ with respect to the yield curve / recession correlation. Hints of the Fed going too far and causing economic damage here.
  • Stephen Roach suggests that the central bankers view the recent market slowness as a correction, and are still interested in slowing the economy to a more moderate pace. Everything looks healthy; we needed this.

So lets add these ideas up a bit. Rising rates & shrinking liquidity, slowing housing markets, tightening lender guidelines… all of this has to cool off the housing market. It has to. It does not guarantee a decline, or correction in housing, but it certainly makes the idea of investing in real estate one where the risk/reward balance has shifted more in the direction of risk. The growth rate cannot be sustained, and we are seeing some hints of this in recent housing data.

It is often argued that real estate is a unique investment, in that a home both an asset, and a place to live. I support this concept, and believe that especially in the long-term view, you cannot go wrong. The media has been talking “Real Estate Bubble” since 2000. If you got scared off then, you missed one heck of a run…

Just some things to consider in the face of an increasingly gloomy economic outlook. Its a moving target. The next few months CPI, GDP, Employment and Housing data will all be interesting to watch, and should provide for further speculation, and hopefully some increased clarity on what comes next.

Bubble, Inflation, Fed, Recession

To get a handle on where the economy is headed exactly is nearly impossible. I am always amazed at the volume of data available and the number of analysts who all look at the same data and come up with wildly different projections.

Today’s Consumer Price Index (CPI) came in showing inflation growth a little higher than the market expected, and the bond market is having a fit over it. This all but guarantees another Fed rate hike for the end of June, and the bond market is adjusting to this ahead of time.

Many economists seem to feel that the Fed historically goes too far when tightening rates, and many believe that we could wind up in a mild recession by the end of the year or early 2007 if they push it any further. Financial markets were clinging to the idea that the Fed would go on ‘pause’ as of the last rate hike, but today’s news is changing the outlook. Ben Bernanke has to be aware that inflation is a lagging indicator, and today’s news reflects 6-24 months ago’s economy, but as the new chairman, he also faces political pressure to appear vigilant in fighting inflation, hence the expectation of another adjustment.

What this means is, if you are going to do something soon, you might consider locking in pricing before it gets any worse. However, I would be hesitant to pay too much up-front for the transaction, since a sputtering economy means that rates should come down again in the next few quarters. If today’s refinance objective is to consolidate debt and lower payments, then don’t wait. But if the Fed goes too far, the odds increase that you may find an opportunity to obtain better rates & terms in the coming months.

If you have questions about how to navigate this market, and make mortgage decisions right now, or about what this chart above means exactly, please email me.

* Graphic courtesy of Mortgage Market Guide

The Shoe Shine Boy has a Tip on a Fabulous 3BR/2BA


I don’t know if it was Joseph Kennedy, John D. Rockefeller, some anonymous millionaire or just an urban legend, but the lesson lives today, and I am afraid that some warning signs are not being fully appreciated. The story goes something like this:

(Insert preferred Robber Baron here) was getting his shoes shined on a sidewalk near Wall Street, circa 1929. The shine boy was bursting at the seams with unsolicited stock tips. The savvy investor took this as a sign that the market was over-extended with a false confidence. Speculators had pitched valuations to unstable highs, setting the stage for a precipitous crash, and the investor cleared out before the stock tips ‘hit the fan’…

Herbert Hoover also blamed the great stock market crash on speculators, suggesting that even “lowly bellboys” were attempting to mimic the legendary returns made by people like Jay Gould and Cornelius Vanderbilt.

This same environmental dynamic also held up under a microscope to the dotcom bust and associated NASDAQ tumble. Volume, valuation, and volatility were all riding high as a deluge of new investors gained easy access to the trading floor, and ignored some of the basics of investing. By and large, they were under-educated in the field of investing, and just like 1929, the fall-out rippled well beyond the speculative investor’s financial world.

So what about housing in today’s market? Clearly there is a bubble watch going on, as values have hit parabolic growth patterns, and sustainability concerns have set in. But housing data continues to be pretty strong, despite the media’s repeated warnings. We have seen statistics suggesting that as much as 40% of the purchase volume in 2005 for houses was for investments or 2nd homes – indicative of speculative buying.

Anybody who has stayed up late once in a while has seen the infomercials catering to get-rich-quick in real estate programs. They usually involve a lot of interview snippets with average people sitting by a pool at some resort in Orlando, quoting their monthly income. They suggest that you should be able to easily buy houses with no investment of your own cash, and tease you to call for more info. And as the frequency of media comments about profits made by investors flipping property, and the huge profits being made in real estate in general, more and more people are sucked into this frenzy for real estate investments. I just worry that the investors are really not taking adequate care to educate themselves about real estate investing, and I sense an instability in this sector of the market.

As I said, the housing industry continues to turn in strong data. Employment growth and income growth are supporting a lot of the gains we have seen in housing costs. The Federal Reserve seems to have a good grip on inflation, and the economy seems healthy, and ready to ease off the throttle a bit. I don’t expect a crash in the values of people’s homes. But to the extent that the market could be bolstered by a false sense of confidence – these investors who don’t know what they’re doing – I would advise exercising some caution when buying anything. History has a tendency to repeat. Be careful following the advice of infomercials.